Part of my coverage of the 62nd Chicago International Film Festival
THE DEBUT ***1/2
IDEA: When she lands a small part in a New Jersey community-theater production of the musical "Nosy Neighbors," housewife Mona Friedman becomes obsessed with getting her character right at all costs, much to the chagrin of ornery director Jerry Blankenbuehler.
BLURB: In Mona Friedman, Jesse Eisenberg has gifted Julianne Moore — and us — with perhaps the ne plus ultra of her roles, an amalgamation of several of her past characters archly dialed up to a fever pitch. She starts off as that most archetypal Moore character: the neglected housewife putting on a brittle performance of domesticity. Wearing a series of pastel sweaters in a brightly-lit home, the camera pressing in on her, Mona grins and speaks with the labored cheer of a woman who’s internalized her pain for so long she doesn’t even know how to be convincingly happy. She has the childlike neediness of May December’s Gracie and the spiritual vacancy of Safe’s Carol, a complacently empty vessel on autopilot waiting to be filled and set in the right direction. That the profoundly broken Mona should find her calling in community theater is both Eisenberg’s sardonic joke and sincere paean to this makeshift haven of outcasts (or in-casts, as she cracks with overeager glee). Watching Mona gain grit, purpose, and agency via the role of Miss Danielle — a role as tertiary to the musical-within-the film as Mona is to her own life — is akin to seeing a baby take its first steps, or, well, an actor get the role of a lifetime and knock it clear out of the auditorium. Moore keeps us on a razor’s edge between tragedy and comedy throughout, from a volcanic rehearsal where her line readings transform into increasingly deranged, improvised expressions of her long-repressed suffering to her mostly disastrous attempts, as Miss Danielle in real life, to fix plumbing and electrical issues in a fleabag motel. In Mona’s total possession by the character of Miss Danielle, The Debut viscerally conveys the physical, emotional, and psychological lure of acting, as well as the anxious thrill of realizing a power you never knew you had. Mona is an absurd character in an absurd movie (one that could arguably use a little more development of its own tertiary, and even secondary, characters), but it’s due to Eisenberg’s and Moore’s absolute commitment to taking her seriously that we do, too. When the lights go up, a star has been born, again.





